Arabic Literature

Quranic Stories and Narratology: Researchers’ Critical Methods and Approaches

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

Soraya Rahimi
Khalil Parvini

PhD Student of Arabic Language and Literature, Tarbiat Modares University

https://doi.org/10.22059/jalit.2020.310613.612283
Abstract
The study of the narrative structure of texts has had a significant influence on literary criticism. This influence has even spread to the analysis of Quranic stories so that these stories have become an arena for the application of the methods of narrative criticism. By examining the articles that have studied the stories of the Quran through these theories, we encounter a large number of works that have employed various methods in their analysis. This study, in order to investigate how narratology is used in the critique of Quranic stories, analyzes the articles written in this field. We do not merely introduce these works, but, with an analytical method, examine different critical approaches in the papers published in scientific-research journals. We have covered the articles published from the last quarter of the twentieth century to the present in Iran, Iraq, and Algeria. We argue that the different approaches of researchers in the study of Quranic stories can be examined in several main areas. Some of these studies have analyzed Quranic stories in a mechanical way by inserting the text into a predetermined framework, so that the analytical part is but a reflection of the theory. A number of researches have made some changes in their method of critique so as to bring a coordination between the text and the theories. And only a few researches have prioritized the text in their attempts at bringing this harmony between the selected theory and the story, and thus, without merlely following the theories, have obtained reliable and novel results. Meanwhile, in a number of studies, we do not see anything but brief references to some methods of narrative criticism, so that the analytical part of these articles is only a personal interpretation of the text without relying on a clear theory in the research.

Keywords

Literary criticism
Critique of criticism
Quranic studies
Modern narratives
Quranic story
Abdolmotalib, M. (1996). Capillary Maneuvers. Cairo: Dar al-Shorugh.  [In Arabic].
Alavi Moqadam, M. (2020). Pathology of Application of Narrative Theories in Iran Academic Reserch. Journal of Narrative, No. 2, 263-299. [In Persian].
Altahan, Y. (2013). Egypt as a Fictional Space in Quran. Abhas Journal, No. 1, 317-338. [In Arabic].
ــــــــــــــ (2010). Narration in Quranic Stories: A Study of Story of Noah. Journal of the College of Islamic Sciences, No. 10, 42-70. [In Arabic].
Amnkhani, E. (2012). Pain or Treatment; Pathology of Application of Literary Theories in Contemporary Research. Journal of Literary Research, No. 36, 51-75. [In Persian].
ــــــــــــــ (2017). The Authority of Theory in Contemporary Literary Research. Journal of Literary Criticism, No. 38, 97-120. [In Persian].
Assafrani, M. (2015). Methods of Announcing Critical Curricula and Critics’ Approach to Methods and Approaches. Taibah University Journal of Arts and Humanities, No. 7, 415-464. [In Arabic].
ــــــــــــــ (2015). Focusing on Quranic and Biblical Narration. Journal of Problems in Language and Literature, No. 2, 10-26. [In Arabic].
Ashrafi, B. (2015). Self-Help in Quranic Stories Based on Propp’s View. Journal of Quranic Literary Research, No. 4, 26-55. [In Persian].
Ben Yusef, R. (2020). Structural Criticism and Fictional Text. Morocco: Efriqia Asharq.  [In Arabic].
Ebrahim, A. (1992). The Arabic Narrative: A Study of the Narrative Structure of the Arab Narrative Heritage. Beirut: Arab Culture Center.  [In Arabic].
ــــــــــــــ (1990). Narrative Visualizer: Critical Approaches to Intertextuality, Visions and Significance. Morocco: Arab Culture Center.  [In Arabic].
ــــــــــــــ (1998). Novel Theory. Cairo: Dar Qoba.  [In Arabic].
Davari Moqadam, F. (2014). A Literary-Linguistic Analysis of the Story of Moses and Khidr from the Perspective of Discourse Systems. Journal of Quranic Literary Research, No. 3, 158-182. [In Persian].
Jabari, R. (2015). The Narrator is Made up of Narrative. Journal of Al-Mustansiriya Literature, No. 71, 213-234. [In Arabic].
Kiani, H. (2013). A Critical Study on the Employment of Flashback in the Story of the Prophet Yusuf. Journal of Studies in Arabic Language and Literature, No. 14, 145-184. [In Arabic].
Mandur, M. (n.d.). Systematic Criticism of the Arabs and the Methodology of Research in Literature and Language. Cairo: Dar al-Nahzah.  [In Arabic].
Mirhoseini, S. M. (2015). An Analytical Look at the Manifestations of the Narrative Discourse in Quran. Anbar University Journal of Languages and Literature, No. 18, 105-126. [In Arabic].
Monavar, A. (1981). Readings in Algerian Literature. Algeria: Sha’ab Library.  [In Arabic].
Munesi, H.  (2010). Narrative Scene in the Quran. Qera’at Journal, No. 2, 229-248. [In Arabic].
Rabiei, M. (2015). Narration in Quranic Storytelling. MaqalidJournal, No. 9, 239-246. [In Arabic].
Samaha, F. (2013). A Structural Criticism of the Arabic Narrative in the Last Quarter of the Twentieth Century. Saudi Arabia: Publications of the Qassim Literary Club.  [In Arabic].
Shakuri, M. (2018). A Narratological Analysis of Conversations between the Arrogant and Their followers in Quran. Journal of Quran and Hadith Studies, No. 1, 53-77. [In Persian].
Torkamani, H. (2017). A Narrative Analysis of Surah Nooh Based on the Views of Barthes and Genet. Journal of Quranic Literary Research, No. 3, 91-116. [In Persian].
ــــــــــــــ (2018). Developing a Structural Model for Surah Studies through Narratology. Journal of Ketab Qayyim, No. 18, 31-61. [In Persian].
Arabic Literature
Volume 12, Issue 3
Autumn 2020
Pages 25-48

  • Receive Date 23 September 2020
  • Revise Date 17 October 2020
  • Accept Date 23 November 2020

Home

Contact Us